Printed from
» To Learn is to live!

Penn State Paterno Out!

Penn State Paterno Out!


Why did he not call the authorities if no one else had done so? Is it enough that he violated no state or federal law?

The “Penn State Scandal,” involves the serious and terrifying crime of child molestation.The paramount inquiry to us is the manner in which Coach Paterno and other Penn State officials responded after being informed of the actions in question.

As of now, no one is accusing Paterno of any crime, or of any failure to follow the rules established by Penn State University. Yet is it enough that Paterno committed no crime? Is it enough that he followed the basic administrative guidelines? Is it enough that he violated no state or federal law?

When Paterno realized that the Penn State administration was not dealing with the situation (or perhaps covering it up), what should he have done? Was he under any further obligation? Even if he was under no legal obligation, is there a difference between the “letter of the law” and the “spirit of the law”?

The Torah states: “Do not stand idly on your brother’s blood” (Leviticus 19:16). This is an imperative to get involved when a situation goes awry. The Almighty created the world as a workshop for self-perfection. No matter what our station in life, no matter what our innate abilities, the Almighty puts us in a particular situation in order that we make the right choice – no matter how uncomfortable or how politically inexpedient.

Our Sages teach that even when there is potential danger to oneself, one is obligated to save another person from certain danger.

Imperative to Act

When the graduate student walked into the shower room and allegedly discovered the horrific acts of the assistant coach, what should he have done? He should have first attempted to stop it. And then he should have walked out and immediately called 911. But he did not.

When the graduate student reported it to Coach Paterno, should Paterno have merely reported it to the school’s Athletic Director? Why did he not call the legal authorities? And if not at that time, why not when he realized that no one else had done so?

Indeed, Paterno and others may have acted “appropriately” under the letter of the law. But to be a role model – to be a hero to young athletes and to thousands of Penn State students and fans – we must demand a bit more.

In a similar vein, the Jewish people have been designated as a light unto the nations. Shall we live merely to the “letter of the law”? Shall we do only what is minimally required of us by secular law or other rules? The Torah says that if you have a chance to fix something in the world – whether stopping your colleague from an illegal act, or helping to feed starving children – and you do not act, then you ultimately bear responsibility. Perhaps, for that reason alone, the firing of Joe Paterno was justified.

Upcoming events
Dec. 16, 2017
Dec. 16, 2017
Shabbat Services with Torah Reading, engaging sermon by Rabbi Perl. Followed by delicious Kiddush
Dec. 19, 2017
Celebrate Chanukah with the newest Chabad Young Professional's Network. Menorah Lighting Live Music, Open Donut Bar, no Charge Delicious Sushi Menorah Platters
Dec. 23, 2017